The Twice-Told Tale
Captain America (Movies)Iron Man (Movies)The Avengers (2012)

The Twice-Told Tale

by arysteia

LIKES

34.6K

CHAPTERS

1

WORDS

15.8K

RATING

4.8

Summary

For someone he'd hero-worshipped for so long, Steve Rogers in the flesh is a pretty big disappointment. For one thing, he keeps looking at Tony as though he reminds him of someone else, and even if he never says anything, Tony's pretty sure it's his father. A lifetime of not measuring up to Howard's expectations is more than enough, thank you very much, and he's certainly not going to make an effort to live up to any of Steve's. Steve's pretty clearly failed to live up to his expectations, in any case, and that's not hypocritical at all.

Reader Reviews

Anonymous

Just now

THIS. I canno't tell you how much I loved this fic. It's so beautiful that I'll just sit here and squee for another hour. Hope you write more in the future :DDD

blakefancier

Just now

This was... wow! Just amazingly wow.

Anonymous

Just now

I have a soft spot for time travel stories where things just suddenly and irrevocably make sense at the end -- and this is one of the best examples of that. Utterly amazing!

LagLemon

Just now

So well done! I was crying for parts of it (I'm not ashamed to say) - so much Tony feels right now.... Awesome story!

Anonymous

Just now

Oh my god you are FANTASTIC. Absolutely brilliant. The thing with Tony and Greg I did not see coming until right before the time jump and it was just. Perfection.

Anonymous

Just now

Oh my goodness. I have so many feelings right now. This was just absolutely amazing. I might have literally squealed out loud at points, and I am not the least bit ashamed. This was beautiful and so very well done. Thank you for writing and sharing this amazing story!

Anonymous

Just now

This was honestly and truly fantastic. I always love time travel stories where things just slot together perfectly. And all of the /feels/. I just can't. You did an amazing job.

Anonymous

Just now

This is perfect!!!!I've been wanting some freaking time-travel fic in this fandom forever, and here it is!Wonderful, loved reading. Great story.

Black_Betty

Just now

THIS WAS AMAAAAAAAAAAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I don't know Iron Man comic-canon very well, so I just assumed that Greg was a real character, and that within your narrative, you made Steve have a wartime affair with him....what ACTALLY happened was SO MUCH BETTER! It wasn't until he went back in time that I realized it, and I literally sat up and said out loud "HE'S GREG. TONY IS GREG." like a big weirdo...LOVED THIS.

Anonymous

Just now

I am this close to doing the Kermit flail. Not usually a fan of time-travel stuff, but that was AWESOME. And I learned a new word - rorts. That's always fun. I need to re-read this to see all the layers of Tony and Howard and Steve hiding what they know from each other.

Anonymous

Just now

As much as I love the Steve/Tony feels here, I am overcome with all the Howard/Tony feels ;_________;

Anonymous

Just now

Okay, so this? This was utter perfection. You made me cry, twice (in the best of ways!) Youve definitely made it on my internal "best authors who can actually write decent steve/tony fic" rec list, probably at the top tbh. I implore you to write more!

panickyintheuk

Just now

Holy crap. You broke me.

Lillian_Shepherd

Just now

Damn it, I didn't see where you were going with that until you actually catapulted Tony back into the past. Great story.

Anonymous

Just now

Oh my goodness, that part at the end with Tony and Howard---I'm in tears. This fic is beautiful.

hufflepuffia

Just now

I loved this! What a fantastic idea, and well done!

umbrellacam

Just now

Oh holy crap, this was absolutely incredible. A much different take on Tony and Steve's relationship than I've seen before, and that's not even counting the star-crossed time-travel aspect! I loved their conflicts, and how it was never easy, but never overdramatic either -- it made things very organic! And lmao I can't believe I didn't see the Greg thing coming, either; since Greg Stark is Tony's twin in Ultimates I figured you were just working a character from comics-canon in in another way, and you were, but alkjskdsdfd \o/!! Tony was the one Steve was making all those plans with! Tony got to come to understanding with Howard (I LOVED THAT)! This was amazing, I don't smoke, but I feel like lounging and having a cigarette, it was so satisfying.STILL, what I wouldn't give for a little epilogue about the aftermath, or something about Steve's POV while this was going on. The first time he saw Tony, omg!! How fucking confusing and emotionally wrecking! Dealing with being unsure about wtf ever went on, then dealing with being sure and the fact that 'Greg' lied to him, and then having to wait, and then finally Tony coming back and them being on the same page -- !! Haha, man, I can tell I'm going to be thinking about this one for a while. It's lovely, thank you for writing and sharing! ♥

thestarsandseas

Just now

This is achingly beautiful. There's such rich emotion and it's such a wonderfully told story and I just feel like I'm completely awkward at trying to express it all. For me personally, the sign of a really well-done story or film is when even after it's finished, my head is still completely filled up with it and your story has done that completely. Beautifully done, thank you.

vaudevilles

Just now

You nailed it.*dances with glee for you*

dee_lirious

Just now

This fic. Just blew my fucking mind. ASKJDHSAKFJH i have no more words.

Bgtea

Just now

Holy crap, my jaw is dropping from the sheer level of awesomeness in this fic. When I first started reading this, I was thinking, "Oh, this fic is going to be fantastic! It's going to have some brilliant characterization of Steve and Tony, they're going to step on each other's toes a lot at first but eventually, they'll come to love each other and have an epic, epic romance. Awesome!"Needless to say, I am very very glad that I was partially right because this fic is so, so much *more*. I did not even see the second half of the fic coming. What a pleasant surprise and how lovely it is that it fits with Steve's description of Greg at the beginning of the fic. I wish I can give you more than one kudos to reflect the amount of love I have for this.

Anonymous

Just now

it's not often i have to read a story twice

Itylien

Just now

For a minute there I was all REAGE there was no time-traveling warning but it's better that way. I thought you went extra creepy what with intergenerational romance and inventing Gregory Stakr for this very purpose and the relief that it wasn't so actually build the fic for me. Thank you!

Pinkelephant42

Just now

This is so, so beautiful. <3

billiontrilliongillian

Just now

Can I just say, NAILED IT.Oh, this was just, ughhhh, it was just perfect.

carzla

Just now

I am flailing at the awesome that this is. And while I have a lot of Steve/Tony feels now, I also have possibly an equal amount of Tony and Howard feels. a;dlkfjasdf;lkjsd Howard figuring out Tony was his son and then telling Tony to remember right at the end that Howard's always loved him. ad;lfkjads;flkjas;dlfjkasdl I CRIED. But all is good. *nods*

Anonymous

Just now

Its beautiful. And twisted. I was like STEVE WHY GREG. Then the time-lapse and i was like TONY HOW COULD YOU

Anitac588

Just now

OMG - I love this story to pieces and I want to give it fifty five kudoses instead of just one. I now need to read it again, this time with the knowledge about Steve and Greg/Tony from a certain point.... So much <3!!!

nolongeractive01

Just now

OH MY GOD. JUST. OH MY GOD.Best time travel fic ever. Period.

Pillow_Face

Just now

Holy... I loved it from the start but then the twist. Just wow! I love a good twist and this one was f***in epic \o/

richardgloucester

Just now

*happy sigh* You brought tears to my eyes.

JiM

Just now

This was just so satisfying and wonderful. I really like Tony coming to a mature understanding of his father. And Steve...oh poor Steve...! Lovely.

Kath Gee (kathgrr)

Just now

Gah, so amazing, completely speechless. You actually made Howard likable yet validating both Steve & Tony's POV. Lovely!

eeyore9990

Just now

God this is gorgeous. A really beautifully told story.

twelve_pastels

Just now

This? Was completely unexpected, and utterly lovely. THANK YOU.

Anonymous

Just now

Ohhh so beautiful. Thanks for this piece of love story...

Anonymous

Just now

Wow. Wow Wow Wow That was amazing and I loved it sooo much I don't even have words thanks for writing have a good day.

pajaro

Just now

Ohhhhhhhhh~ Emotions. I have so many of them. Tony. Steve. I can't believe he knew all that time. Such an incredible story. Thank you for writing and sharing it. ;)

sethra2000

Just now

Ahhhhhh, I've been having a wonderful love affair with these two since the movie came out, and this was brilliant. Glad to see you writing them.

momentarygrace

Just now

Thank you for taking the time to build everything slowly and thoroughly - Steve & Tony's relationship in particular. The time travel was unexpected but absolutely perfectly done. I have a lot of respect for you and a lot of love for the story. By putting Tony in the past you enabled yourself to comment on the events of the CA movie in a very personal and intimate way, as well as filling out Howard so beautifully and giving Tony a relationship with his old man that works. Many A+'s. :)

immoral_crow

Just now

Utterly splendid. I adore the idea Tony got to know his father. It punched me right in the feels.

Anonymous

Just now

I can barely remember the last time a fic had me speechless, gasping and making me squee in delight. I can only say this was rich, very well written and very great plot planned. I REALLY, REALLY hope you can write more stories like this, let alone more fics. Because I seriously have no words to describe how much I loved this. The beginning where you think 'how this will end if they push each other nerves' to the very moment at the end after you realize what the hell happened all this time. I think I'm in love with this story LMAO.

Anonymous

Just now

Oh goodness. This. This is absolutely stunning.At first I had no clue as to why Steve was making such a big deal over Greg but then Tony went back in time and my breath was stolen from me. All of those plans were made by the two of them and oh gosh, it hurts so nice. A love that encompassed so much time.And the relationship between Howard and Tony is done perfectly. It's always interesting to see how different author handle the dynamics that the MCU and I love your take. Howard was no evil incarnate and did in fact love his son. I can't wait to re-read to find the hints that I missed.Absolutely lovely! Thank you for writing and sharing :)

kanikan

Just now

Wow... originality off the charts. Wonderful story... don't have better words than those :)

Anonymous

Just now

OMG I CRIED SO HARD IT WAS SO BEAUTIFUL *dissolves into ugly tears*

windsweptfic

Just now

Oh man, this was just fantastic.

The Black Sluggard (Hazgarn)

Just now

This is one of the most impressive things I've ever read. I love time-travel romance like nobody's business and this worked the parallels so beautifully. I don't know why I never made the connection between Erksine and Yinsen, and the Howard, and I loved so much how perfectly Tony's man-out-of-time experiences reflected Steve's. It was massively, incredibly brilliant.

Anonymous

Just now

UNEXPECTED TIME TRAVEL!!!!!!!!! YEAH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Anonymous

Just now

This was excellent. I misted up at the end. Thank you!

veganoween

Just now

I had to read it three times. It's so perfect. guh.